The Best Hot Sauce Subscription Boxes

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Pepper Geek takes part in various affiliate programs. This means that purchases through our links may result in a commission for us.

A hot sauce subscription box is the perfect way to discover new sauce brands and flavors. If you’re anything like us, your fridge is packed with hot sauce, but there’s always room for a few more bottles.

We’re going to talk about some of the best hot sauce subscription boxes so you can get your regular spicy sauce fix delivered right to your door. These subscription boxes also make a fantastic gift for even the pickiest of hot sauce lovers.

1. Heat Hot Sauce Club

Hot Sauce Subscription Box

Formed by two young chileheads out of California, the Heat Hot Sauce box is the most customizable hot sauce subscription we’ve seen yet. You can choose from “mellow sauces that focus on flavor”, or singe your tastebuds with extra hot sauces reserved for die-hard chileheads.

If you prefer a variety, sign up for the classic box, which includes sauces from all heat levels. If you don’t use hot sauce up too quickly, you can even opt for a single bottle membership.

If you don’t want to commit to a hot sauce subscription box, Heat Hot Sauce also offers many hot sauce gift sets featuring the best sauces on the market.

2. The Hot Ones Box

Hot Ones 3 New Sauce bottle labels: The Las Dab Chile De Arbol Edition, Los Calientes Rojo, and The Classic Pepper X Edition

If you’re a fan of the Hot Ones show, this is the box for you. With each monthly subscription, you’ll have early access to try new sauces from each season. We’re always impressed by the quality of products that arrive in the Hot Ones box. The customer service is outstanding if you have questions about a product or issues with your order.

The novelty of this box combined with the quality of sauces makes this one of our favorite hot sauce subscription services. You can even opt in for a year-long subscription if you’re a true chilehead!

3. Fuego Box

Hot Sauce Subscription Box

Fuego Box is another great way to try delicious craft hot sauces. The Fuego Box company holds regular tasting parties of all the new sauces sent to them, so you know you’re getting fantastic products that have been hand-picked by the team.

We appreciate that they focus on flavor over gimmicky “too hot to handle” sauces. With different subscription plans to choose from, you can decide just how spicy you want to get. Fuego Box also makes it easy to gift a subscription to a friend or family member if you’re looking to spice up someone else’s day.

See our full review of Fuego Box here.

Tip: Sign up to their email list to unlock $10 off your first box.

4. Hot Sauce Lover Membership

Doc Hotties Box

The Hot Sauce Lover Membership (formally known as Doc Hotties) is a flexible subscription for hot sauce lovers. You can choose a single bottle subscription service or a two bottle service in the heat level of your choosing. You can also choose on monthly delivery or opt for delivery every 3 months if you don’t see yourself using the bottle too quickly.

5. Queen Creek Olive Mill

Queen Creek Sauces

Queen Creek Olive Mill offers a subscription service that includes not just hot sauces, but BBQ sauces as well. Choose a membership ranging from 3-12 months and you’ll have one delicious hot (or not) sauce shipped to your door every month. They also have some great olive oil gift sets if you’re looking for something a little different.

Looking for some hot sauce recommendations? Check out our best hot sauces article here.

Are you subscribed to any of these hot sauce subscription boxes? If so, let us know what your thoughts were!


Crystalyn loves spicy food and getting creative in the kitchen. When she isn’t finding new ways to use hot sauce, shes very busy watching cat videos on the internet.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *