Skip to Content

Bahamian Goat Pepper – A Quirky and Fruity Chili

Some of the hottest peppers have origins in the Caribbean. While the Bahamian goat pepper is not among the spiciest, is is one of my personal favorites from the West Indies.

With a name like ‘goat pepper,’ you will likely have some questions about the variety. In this article, I’ll share everything I know about the Bahamian goat pepper, including flavor, appearance, origin, and growth habits.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Pepper Geek participates in various affiliate programs, meaning links contained in this article may provide us a commission should you make a purchase on the linked website.

Bahamian Goat pepper
Ripe Bahamian goat pepper.

Name and Origin

As we’ve established, the goat pepper comes from the Bahamas and is from the Capsicum chinense species. It is similar to the scotch bonnet in terms of flavor, but has a much stranger appearance, some say like a pumpkin.

Bahamian Goat pepper top
Bahamian goat pepper from the top.

Where does the name come from? The origin of the goat pepper’s name is uncertain, but there are a few common theories. One is that the pepper has a spicy ‘kick’ similar to an angry goat’s powerful kick. Another is that the pepper is ugly, like a goat.

Another possible reason is that goats and other livestock are commonly raised in the Bahamas. The peppers are therefore commonly found growing nearby actual goats. And finally, when cut open, goat peppers release a powerful aroma that some say smells like a goat (though is disagree).

Fun read: Read Patrick Holian’s story about his visit to the Bahamas and his quest to find out why the goat pepper is so named.


Goat Pepper Scoville (Heat)

The goat pepper has a powerful heat, but it certainly is not among the hottest I have tasted. This makes the Bahamian goat pepper a great candidate for making usable hot sauce.

The Bahamian Goat pepper has a Scoville rating between 100,000-300,000 SHUs. This heat level is in line with a common habanero pepper that you might buy at a grocery store.

Bahamian Goat pepper bottom
Large Bahamian goat pepper.

While heat is similar to habaneros, the flavor is commonly regarded as much better, and I couldn’t agree more!


Bahamian Goat Pepper Flavor and Recipes

One of the standout attributes of the goat pepper is its wonderful flavor and aroma. Just slicing one in half releases a potpourri of lemon, flowers, and pepper into the air.

If you’re brave enough to take a bite of one raw, the flavor is fruity and citrusy, with obvious notes of lemon. The amount you eat is directly correlated to how hot it will be, so start with a small nibble.

Ripe Bahamian Goat peppers
Two goat peppers.

Even better, use the goat pepper to enhance the flavor and experience of an authentic Bahamian dish. Goat peppers are commonly used to make spicy conch salad, fried chicken, and more.


Bahamian Goat Pepper Seeds and Growing

If you want to get your hands on some Bahamian goat peppers, chances are you’ll have to grow them. Unless you live in the Caribbean, these peppers are hard to find fresh.

Thankfully, seeds are easy to find online, and growing them is no different than growing habaneros.

Unripe Bahamian Goat Pepper
Unripe Bahamian goat pepper on plant.

The plants are fairly vigorous, and tend to produce dense collections of peppers. Here in New England, we did struggle with some fungal issues on the peppers. This may have been due to the plant’s tendency to grow tight bunches of leaves, leading to poor airflow.

Otherwise, the plant is productive and easy to grow. As with many chinense species peppers, the Bahamian goat pepper takes a long time to ripen, so be sure to plant early indoors!


Read Next:

I hope this article has inspired you to try the amazing Bahamian goat pepper yourself. It is a beautifully quirky and delicious pepper that is the perfect substitute for habaneros in your garden.

Calvin Thumbnail

Calvin

One of the original Pepper Geeks! When Calvin isn’t gardening or learning more about peppers and botany, he might be traveling new places or playing some music.